Dealing with cross-border tax issues can be complicated, especially when two countries disagree on how you should be taxed. That’s where the Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) comes in, a formal process designed to help resolve these kinds of disputes under international tax treaties. If you’re facing a tax disagreement involving Malta, understanding how MAP works can be a valuable step toward a fair resolution.
In this guide, we will break down the key aspects of MAP, how it operates in Malta, and what taxpayers need to know to effectively request assistance.
What is MAP?
MAP is a dispute resolution mechanism established under double tax treaties between two countries, allowing taxpayers to resolve conflicts regarding the interpretation or application of tax agreements.
For Malta, the Competent Authority – the Minister responsible for finance or their authorised representative – manages the MAP process. The aim is to ensure that taxation occurs in accordance with the applicable treaty, preventing instances of double taxation.
How Does MAP Work?
MAP enables the Competent Authorities of the two Contracting States (countries involved in the tax agreement) to communicate directly, exchanging information and reaching a resolution. The process is available for various tax-related issues, such as:
- Transfer pricing adjustments
- Attribution of profits to permanent establishments
- Dual residence issues for individuals or entities
- Withholding taxes exceeding the treaty limits
- Disputes related to anti-abuse provisions in tax treaties
If a taxpayer believes they have been unfairly taxed, they can request MAP to resolve the issue.
The Process of Making a MAP Request
The first step for a taxpayer is to raise the issue with the relevant tax authorities in writing. It’s advisable that taxpayers contact the Competent Authority in both the relevant countries involved to facilitate a quicker resolution.
The request should include all necessary supporting documentation and be submitted within the time period specified by the relevant treaty. Typically, the MAP request must be made within three years from the first notification of the disputed tax action.
Key Information for a MAP Request
To make sure your MAP request is processed, you must provide the following information:
- Personal and business details of the taxpayer, including tax reference numbers
- Details of the foreign tax administration and the period of assessment
- A summary of the facts and issues that led to the request
- Applicable articles of the relevant tax treaties
- Any prior objections or claims made with the other Contracting State
- Supporting documents like tax assessments, financial statements, and correspondence with tax authorities
If the request involves transfer pricing adjustments, additional details will be required, such as:
- Details of associated enterprises involved in the adjustment
- Calculations for the proposed adjustment
- Transfer pricing policies or documentation, including agreements between the related entities
Timeline for MAP Resolution
Once the Malta Competent Authority receives the MAP request, it will evaluate whether the case is justified. If so, the Competent Authority will acknowledge the request and initiate the process with the other Contracting State. The goal is to resolve the case within 24 months, though the timeline may vary depending on the complexity of the issue.
The Competent Authority will keep the taxpayer informed, providing updates every 90 days. While taxpayers don’t have the right to directly participate in negotiations between the Competent Authorities, in some cases, the Competent Authorities may agree to allow the taxpayer to present relevant facts.
Appealing a MAP Decision
If the taxpayer is dissatisfied with the resolution of a MAP case, they have the right to withdraw from the process and pursue any available domestic legal avenues, including an appeal. However, if the MAP request was initiated due to actions under the Income Tax Acts (e.g., an audit settlement), the Malta Competent Authority cannot change a final tax assessment.
How MAP Cases Are Concluded
Once the Competent Authorities resolve a MAP case, the details of the resolution are communicated to the taxpayer. If the taxpayer agrees with the resolution, it will be implemented by the Maltese tax authorities without delay. Typically, this process takes about three months from the agreement between the Competent Authorities.
Suspension of Tax Collection During MAP
In some cases, the collection of disputed tax may be suspended while the MAP process is underway. Under Malta’s Income Tax Management Act, any part of the tax in dispute can be held in abeyance if the taxpayer has filed an objection or appeal against the relevant assessment.
Interest Considerations During MAP
While the MAP process is in effect, interest on any tax payable is suspended. This means that no interest will accrue on the disputed tax amount from the date the MAP process is initiated until the case is concluded.
Confidentiality and Use of Taxpayer Information
The information provided during the MAP process is strictly confidential. The Malta Competent Authority will ensure that sensitive data, such as trade secrets or proprietary information, is protected throughout the dispute resolution process. The use of such information is strictly governed by Maltese law and international tax treaties.
Conclusion
The Mutual Agreement Procedure is an essential mechanism for resolving international tax disputes that provides a structured way for taxpayers to challenge unfair tax assessments. By following the outlined process and submitting the necessary documentation, taxpayers can resolve their issues with the tax authorities in a timely and efficient manner.
If you are considering requesting MAP assistance in Malta, it is crucial to understand the requirements and deadlines involved. With the right approach, MAP can provide a fair resolution to tax disputes, ensuring compliance with international tax agreements while protecting taxpayers’ rights.
Need help understanding taxes in Malta? Feel free to reach out!
English 
Danish 
French 
German